Tampered Temp Worker Files: Edited EADs, Licenses and Certificates
How U.S. staffing firms catch an altered work authorization document, driver's license or safety certificate in a temp worker file: which field is compared with which source, and what to do on a mismatch.

Summarize this article with
A falsified work authorization document in a staffing file is usually a normal document with one field changed: an expiration date pushed out, a category code swapped, a name replaced. The edit becomes visible when that field is compared with a second source, either another document in the file or a government database. The same logic covers edited driver's licenses and safety certificates.
This article covers the U.S. position as of November 2026. It describes what each comparison looks at and what the reviewer does when one fails. A mismatch shows two sources disagree; agreement does not prove a document is genuine. Rules differ by state and change, so treat this as general information.
What do edited work documents, licenses and certificates look like?
Most edits touch one field, because every extra change creates another mismatch. Three patterns recur in staffing files.
- Work authorization: an Employment Authorization Document (EAD) or Permanent Resident Card scan with a later expiration date, a changed category code, or a different name or A-Number dropped in.
- Driver's license: added endorsements or classes (for example a commercial class), a changed expiration date, or a genuine license belonging to someone else with the candidate's name typed over it.
- Certificates: a real forklift or safety certificate where the name, training date or equipment type was replaced, or a template filled in with a made-up training provider.
A free image editor and a genuine original are enough. That is why the check must lean on a source the applicant does not supply.
Which field is compared with which source?
Every editable field has a counterpart elsewhere. The table sets out the comparisons for a temp worker file, what a mismatch looks like, and the reviewer's next step.
| Field on the document | Compared with | What a mismatch looks like | Reviewer's next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| EAD or green card: expiration date, category | Form I-9 Section 1 and 2 entries; E-Verify case result where the firm participates | Document copy shows a later date than the I-9 entry, or E-Verify returns a tentative nonconfirmation | Follow the E-Verify steps, do not terminate on suspicion alone, record both |
| Document type and List A/B/C choice | Form I-9 Section 2 | Document listed does not match the one actually presented | Correct with a dated, initialed note under Form I-9 correction rules |
| Name, date of birth on the document | Section 1 attestation, SSN record, payroll form, state ID | Transposed letters, day and month swapped, different surname | Ask for the original, correct typos in writing, escalate if unexplained |
| Driver's license: class, endorsements, expiration | The original license and a state motor vehicle record where the job requires driving | Scan shows a class the original lacks | Authorize only classes seen on the original |
| Forklift certificate: name, date, equipment | The employer's own evaluation and the training provider's record | Provider has no record of the person | Request a replacement from the provider and re-evaluate the operator |
| Certificate validity or training date | First day of the assignment | Valid in the file, out of date on the start day | Delay the start or require refresher training |
| PDF or image file properties | Stated issue date | Created in an image editor after the stated issue | A flag to compare with another source, never proof alone |
The strongest comparisons run against a record the applicant cannot edit, because anyone altering a document can change every copy they hold, but not a federal or state database or the training provider's records.
What do Form I-9 and E-Verify prove, and what do they not?
The Form I-9 instructions tell employers to accept documents that reasonably appear to be genuine and to relate to the employee, as the Justice Department's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section summarizes. Employers must not specify which documents from the lists an employee presents. The USCIS employer guidance explains how Section 2 is completed. This rule shapes the whole tampering workflow: a staffing firm is not expected to be a forensic examiner, and over-demanding documents can itself be discriminatory.
E-Verify adds a comparison. It checks the information from the Form I-9 against government records, which is the closest thing to an independent source for work authorization. The E-Verify program is voluntary for most employers, so whether you have this layer depends on your contracts and state law. Neither tool confirms that the person presenting a document is its owner. The photo comparison, where a document has a photo, remains the reviewer's job. Neither says anything about a license or a safety certificate.
For the staffing firm, the legal exposure sits with the employer of record. Knowingly hiring or continuing to employ an unauthorized worker is prohibited under the Immigration and Nationality Act, and the Justice Department also enforces against unfair documentary practices. Confirm penalty levels and current guidance with counsel rather than relying on a summary.
Ready to automate your checks?
Free pilot with your own documents. Results in 48h.
Request a free pilotHow are licenses and safety certificates checked?
They are checked with the body that issued them, because the document is the thing in doubt. For driving roles, compare the original license with government photo ID, and where the job requires it, obtain a motor vehicle record through the process your insurer and state rules allow. Authorize only the classes and endorsements you saw on the original.
For forklift operators, OSHA's standard at 29 CFR 1910.178 puts certification on the employer: the employer must certify that each operator was trained and evaluated. A card from a previous employer or a training company is therefore evidence to compare, not a substitute for the employer's own evaluation. Contact the training provider using details you sourced yourself, not those printed on the card. Our article on forklift certification verification for warehouse temps covers the fields to compare.
What does the reviewer do when a field does not match?
A mismatch is a reason to stop and ask, not a finding of fraud. Most differences in staffing files are typing errors, names written two ways or outdated copies.
- Hold the start date for that worker until the point is resolved.
- Go to the source: re-check the original, run the E-Verify steps if you participate, or contact the issuer. Treat the supplied copy as unreliable until it agrees.
- Ask the worker, in writing, for the original and an explanation, with neutral wording: "the copy and the source differ".
- Contact the issuer of a certificate or license and note the date, person and answer.
- Record the outcome and keep both versions.
- Escalate to compliance or counsel if the explanation does not hold, or if the same pattern appears across several workers from one source. Take legal advice before contacting the client or authorities about a possible offense.
Apply the same process to every worker. Singling out workers by appearance or accent invites discrimination claims. Immigration data in the file should be limited to those who need it, in line with state privacy law, for example the California Consumer Privacy Act where it applies.
What do recruiters and staffing coordinators ask?
"The worker texted a photo of their EAD. Is that enough?" No. Complete the I-9 with the original document in your presence, or through the authorized remote procedure if you use E-Verify, and keep the record.
"The forklift card is fine but the last name has an extra letter." Treat it as a mismatch. Ask the provider for the correct spelling and correct your file only after you hear back.
"The client says it already checked." The staffing firm is the employer of record for its workers. The client's check does not replace yours.
How does a validation tool help without overstating it?
A validation run compares fields across the file: names, dates of birth, document numbers and expiration dates against the start date. It shows which field differs on which document so the reviewer does not re-read every page. It does not certify a document is genuine and does not replace an E-Verify result or the issuer's confirmation. Where tampering is the concern, CheckFile's document fraud detection page describes AI-generation signals as a complement to your existing controls. For everyday completeness checks, see CheckFile for temporary staffing and the industry verification pillar guide. Related: tampered candidate files and first assignment document checks.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules change and vary by state; confirm current requirements with USCIS, the Department of Justice or qualified counsel. Reviewed by the CheckFile editorial team, November 18, 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a staffing firm rely on a copy of an EAD?
Not on its own. Complete Form I-9 with the original document, compare its fields with the other records, and keep a copy for the file. A copy cannot show the current status.
How do you spot an altered work authorization document?
Compare expiration date, category, name and date of birth with the Form I-9 entries, the E-Verify result if you use it, and the other documents. The difference between sources is the signal.
Does a mismatch between two documents prove forgery?
No. Spelling variants, swapped dates and outdated copies are far more common than forgery. A mismatch justifies holding the start, checking the source and requesting the original.
How do you verify a forklift certificate?
Remember that OSHA places certification on the employer. Contact the training provider through independently found details and confirm name, date and equipment, then complete your own evaluation.
What should be kept after a check?
The completed I-9, any E-Verify case result, the check date, who ran it and correspondence about a mismatch, with limited access.
Stay informed
Get our compliance insights and practical guides delivered to your inbox.